Product Manager, Mentor-Side Marketplace

Athlete to Athlete
Santa Monica, CA
On-site

Who this role is best for

Strong fit for product managers with hands-on experience in consumer tech and marketplace dynamics who thrive in cross-functional, fast-moving startup environments.

Best fit for

  • Product managers with experience in consumer technology and two-sided marketplaces, especially on the supply side
    — “Experience building or scaling a two-sided marketplace, particularly on the supply side.”
  • Individuals who can synthesize mentor feedback and data into actionable product improvements
    — “Use mentor feedback, session insights, and performance data to identify opportunities for targeted training and continuous improvement.”

Things to consider

  • The role demands significant cross-functional collaboration and quick decision-making in a startup setting
    — “This is a highly hands-on, cross-functional role that blends product strategy, marketplace analytics, experimentation, and operational execution.”
  • Candidates should be prepared for a scrappy environment with a focus on rapid iteration and problem-solving
    — “comfortable moving quickly, testing ideas, and solving problems in a scrappy startup environment.”

How to stand out

  • Highlight mentor-side product improvements and AI integration in your resume and portfolio
    — “Explore how AI and emerging technologies can make session preparation, personalized guidance, and ongoing mentor development more seamless and effective.”
  • Emphasize your ability to own and improve mentor lifecycle experiences from recruitment to retention
    — “Own the mentor journey from recruitment and onboarding through activation, engagement, and long-term retention.”
  • Showcase your analytical approach to product decisions and marketplace health metrics
    — “Leverage product analytics, qualitative research, and structured prioritization frameworks to make informed decisions.”
Pace · Fast PacedCollaboration · HighAutonomy · MediumDecision Impact · Company

Derived from job-description analysis by Serendipath's career intelligence engine.

What success looks like

  • Own the mentor journey
  • Build mentor training programs
  • Drive marketplace health
  • Partner with Sales, Marketing, and Operations
Typical background
Product management experienceExperience in tech-forward platforms

Skills & requirements

Required

Product ManagementMarketplace HealthMentor LifecycleMentor TrainingAI IntegrationMarketplace AnalyticsExperimentationOperational Execution

Preferred

PythonSQLData AnalysisProduct Strategy

Stack & domain

Product ManagementAIPersonalized TrainingIntuitive Product ToolsMentorshipMarketplace HealthLiquidityMulti-language EcosystemsPythonLeadershipCommunicationTeamworkProblem-solvingAdaptabilityAthlete DevelopmentTech-forward Platform

About the role

Original posting from Athlete to Athlete via Lever

About Athlete To Athlete

At Athlete To Athlete, we are building a more connected future for athlete development. We believe athletes grow best when they are supported by meaningful relationships, experienced mentorship, and communities that genuinely care about their success.

Athlete To Athlete is a human-first, tech-forward platform that connects young athletes with accomplished college athletes who are actively living the journey themselves. Since launching four years ago, we have worked with more than 35,000 athletes, grown more than 100% every year, and are on track to facilitate more than 100,000 mentorship sessions this year. We are a Series A company building the team that will take us through our next stage of growth.

About the Role

We're looking for a Product Manager, Mentor-Side Marketplace to own and elevate the entire mentor experience at Athlete To Athlete.

You'll be the voice of the mentor, owning the experience of attracting, developing, and supporting exceptional college athlete mentors. A major focus will be leveraging AI, personalized training, and intuitive product tools to make session preparation effortless and continuous mentor development a natural part of the platform.

You'll also own mentor marketplace health and liquidity, ensuring we have the right supply of high-quality mentors across sports, positions, and availability to meet family demand. You'll partner closely with Sales, Marketing, and Operations to continuously improve the mentor experience and marketplace performance.

This is a highly hands-on, cross-functional role that blends product strategy, marketplace analytics, experimentation, and operational execution. You'll work closely with Design and Engineering to build scalable solutions while remaining comfortable moving quickly, testing ideas, and solving problems in a scrappy startup environment.

What You'll Do:

Own the Mentor Lifecycle & Experience

-

Own the mentor journey from recruitment and onboarding through activation, engagement, and long-term retention.

-

Serve as the voice of our college athlete mentors, deeply understanding their needs, motivations, challenges, and feedback.

-

Partner with Marketing and Operations to build scalable programs for recruiting and activating high-quality college athlete mentors.

-

Continuously improve the mentor-facing platform, removing friction and creating an intuitive, engaging experience that mentors genuinely enjoy using.

Build the Best Mentor Training & Enablement Experience

-

Own the strategy and evolution of our mentor training programs, development resources, and educational content library.

-

Build systems that help mentors continuously improve their coaching, communication, leadership, and mentorship skills.

-

Explore how AI and emerging technologies can make session preparation, personalized guidance, and ongoing mentor development more seamless and effective.

-

Embed preparation tools, recommended activities, relevant resources, and actionable insights directly into the mentor workflow so that delivering great sessions becomes second nature.

-

Develop scalable ways to help mentors understand each youth athlete's goals, track progress, and arrive at every session confident and prepared.

-

Use mentor feedback, session insights, and performance data to identify opportunities for targeted training and continuous improvement.

Drive Marketplace Health & Liquidity

-

Develop a deep understanding of mentor supply and family demand across sports, positions, availability, mentor quality, and other key marketplace dimensions.

-

Own and improve marketplace health metrics, including mentor activation, availability, utilization, match rates, engagement, and retention.

-

Partner with Sales, Marketing, and Operations to anticipate supply gaps, improve marketplace balance, and ensure families have access to exceptional mentors.

-

Build reporting and analytical frameworks to identify opportunities and guide marketplace decisions.

Lead Product Development & Experimentation

-

Define and prioritize the mentor-side product roadmap, partnering closely with Engineering and Design to ship impactful improvements.

-

Develop hypotheses, run A/B tests, analyze results, and continuously optimize mentor experiences and marketplace performance.

-

Leverage product analytics, qualitative research, and structured prioritization frameworks to make informed decisions.

-

Balance longer-term product investments with quick, practical solutions, recognizing that not every problem requires engineering.

What We're Looking For:

-

4+ years of Product Management experience, ideally in consumer technology, marketplaces, or other operationally complex businesses.

-

Strong analytical skills and a track record of using data to identify opportunities, prioritize initiatives, and measure outcomes.

-

Experience running A/B tests, developing hypotheses, and applying experimentation and product prioritization frameworks.

-

Strong product and UX instincts, with experience building intuitive, engaging consumer-facing experiences.

-

Familiarity with AI-powered products and an eagerness to apply emerging technologies to solve real user problems.

-

Comfort working hands-on with analytics tools, dashboards, and funnel metrics. SQL experience is a plus.

-

Excellent cross-functional collaboration skills across Engineering, Design, Marketing, Sales, and Operations.

-

A bias toward action, strong ownership mentality, and comfort navigating ambiguity in a fast-moving startup.

-

Strong communication skills and the ability to turn complex challenges into clear, actionable solutions.

Nice to Have:

-

Experience building or scaling a two-sided marketplace, particularly on the supply side.

-

Experience with marketplace liquidity, supply acquisition, activation, utilization, or retention.

-

Experience building training, learning, enablement, or professional development products.

-

Experience applying AI to personalization, content recommendations, coaching, or workflow automation.

-

Background in gig economy platforms, creator marketplaces, talent networks, or educational technology.

-

A passion for sports, college athletics, mentorship, or youth development.

Compensation:

Athlete to Athlete is an Equal Opportunity Employer.  We are committed to providing a workplace free from discrimination and harassment.  We do not discriminate on the basis of legally protected characteristics under applicable federal, state or local law.

Athlete to Athlete is also committed to providing reasonable accommodations to qualified candidates and employees with disabilities. If you need a reasonable accommodation during the application or interview process, please let the recruiter know.

Source: Athlete to Athlete careers (Lever)

Similar roles