Case Manager, Liability, Evidence & Claims

Finch
United States
Remote

Who this role is best for

Aimed at mid-level to senior legal professionals with pre-litigation experience who thrive in a fast-paced startup environment and can manage complex insurance and public records workflows remotely.

Best fit for

  • Candidates with a background in personal injury pre-litigation and insurance claim management
    — “Personal Injury Pre-Litigation Specialist to support case management from intake through settlement preparation”
  • Individuals who have systematically handled evidence collection and FOIA requests across multiple jurisdictions
    — “drafting and managing FOIA / public records requests and obtaining police reports across multiple jurisdictions”
  • Professionals who enjoy process optimization and automation in a rapidly evolving startup setting
    — “analyze workflow inefficiencies ... identify automation opportunities, and implement process improvements”

Things to consider

  • The role demands high attention to detail and systematic follow-up for evidence and records tracking
    — “highly detail-oriented, organized, and energized by working in a fast-paced startup environment”

How to stand out

  • Highlight experience in managing complex evidence workflows and insurance communication
    — “managing ongoing communication with insurance carriers and government agencies”
  • Showcase a history of preparing case packages for legal teams based on evidence analysis
    — “prepare comprehensive case packages for lead paralegals to draft settlement demands”
Pace · Fast PacedCollaboration · MediumAutonomy · MediumDecision Impact · Team

Derived from job-description analysis by Serendipath's career intelligence engine.

Skills & requirements

Required

Personal Injury Pre-litigationFOIA And Public Records RequestsEvidence CollectionCase Management

Preferred

Legal TechnologyProcess Improvement

Stack & domain

FOIAPublic Records RequestsPolice ReportsDash Cam/body Cam Footage911 RecordingsMedical RecordsLiability AnalysisAttention To DetailExcitement For Fast-paced Startup EnvironmentConsumer LawPersonal Injury Pre-litigation

About the role

Original posting from Finch via Ashby

ABOUT FINCH

We’re building the applied AI platform for consumer law.

Legal is the largest services market in the global economy, and consumer law drives tangible, customer outcomes. Our purpose-built platform combines AI agents and legal operators to reduce manual work, enabling firms to serve far more people and expand access to justice. 77% of Americans who'd benefit from a lawyer never get one and we’re broadening how technology impacts real life outcomes.

We’ve started with consumer law (a $120B+ market), and demand has come fast: more than 150 firms run on Finch; we're growing 1,000%+ year-over-year.

Finch was founded by a team of technologists and operators from backgrounds across scale-ups, legal operators, enterprise software, and financial institutions, and law firms. We’re backed by top VCs like Sequoia and Redpoint, and consistently looking to add top talent who wants to build in AI.

Explore life at Finch https://app.notion.com/p/Life-at-Finch-32fe7a322002810cabf6f9547800f2a2?source=copy_link for more.

THIS ROLE: CASE MANAGER, LIABILITY, EVIDENCE & CLAIMS

We are seeking an experienced Personal Injury Pre-Litigation Specialist to support case management from intake through settlement preparation. The ideal candidate has hands-on experience gathering and organizing liability evidence, conducting fault analysis, and managing ongoing communication with insurance carriers and government agencies.

This role also requires experience handling the full evidence and records collection process, including drafting and submitting FOIA and public records requests, obtaining police reports and supplemental narratives, securing dash cam/body cam footage and 911 audio, tracking outstanding records across jurisdictions, and ensuring accurate documentation throughout the lifecycle of the claim.

The ideal candidate is highly detail-oriented, organized, and energized by working in a fast-paced startup environment where processes are evolving and ownership is expected.

WHAT YOU'LL DO:

  • Open insurance claims with all relevant carriers (liability, UM/UIM, med pay), send letters of representation, obtain claim numbers and adjuster assignments, and manage ongoing carrier communication including acknowledgment follow-up
  • Draft and submit FOIA and public records requests to police departments, state agencies, and municipal offices; track request status, escalate non-responsive agencies, and ensure timely receipt of police reports, supplemental narratives, dash/body cam footage, and 911 recordings
  • Request and track medical records, witness statements, scene photographs, and other essential evidence; implement systematic follow-up protocols to ensure timely receipt and flag non-responsive parties for escalation
  • Conduct liability analysis from police reports, witness statements, and scene evidence; assess fault allocation, comparative negligence exposure, and evidentiary gaps; prepare comprehensive case packages for lead paralegals to draft settlement demands
  • Analyze workflow inefficiencies in evidence collection and case setup processes, identify automation opportunities, and implement process improvements to reduce cycle time from intake to demand-ready status

YOU MIGHT BE A FIT IF YOU:

  • Have experience in personal injury pre-litigation
  • Have experience drafting and managing FOIA / public records requests and obtaining police reports across multiple jurisdictions
  • Have experience opening claims, creating all coverage-related documentation, and managing relationships with insurance providers
  • Have experience conducting liability analysis and organizing evidence (police reports, photos, video, witness statements) into case-ready packages
  • Attention to detail and excitement for a fast-paced startup environment

COMPENSATION

  • $60,000 – $85,000 annual salary + equity

ADDITIONAL BENEFITS INCLUDE:

  • 100% coverage for health, dental, and vision
  • 401(k) retirement plan
  • Flexible PTO (we trust you to take the time you need)

Source: Finch careers (Ashby)

Similar roles

More roles at Finch